Tuesday, March 02, 2010

Living la vida ahora

It's like the good old days, reading a friend's blog and being inspired to riff off something found there...

Via Derek, who found the link at the Blogora, comes this 2007 New Yorker article on the language of the Piraha, a "remote Amazonian tribe." The article is, as Jim Aune commented when posting the link, fascinating on many levels.

The primary focus is on the challenge that the linguist Dan Everett's interpretation of the language poses to Chomsky's notion of universal grammar. What the Piraha language seems to lack is the very thing that Chomsky and his associates have posited as the key feature of human language: recursion, the embedding of one phrase into another. So, rather than saying the equivalent of "The man who lives downstream fell in the river," they would say something like, "The man lives downstream. He fell in the river." Their expressions are what prescriptive grammarians would call simple sentences. There's no sentence combining here.

Going along with this grammatical feature is a kind of radical empiricism. They speak of what they can see or of what someone they know has seen. While all language is abstract, they seem to eschew abstractions that are more than one degree removed from the concrete. Thus, they have no words for colors. Rather, they refer to color by way of simile, but without fixing upon a simile. According to the article, they might describe a red cup as looking like blood, but at another time say that it looks like a certain kind of berry.

They have no mythic origin stories, which makes me wonder if they have no particular religion. When missionaries have translated parts of the Bible into their language (a task that is itself apparently extraordinarily difficult), they have no sense of it as "spiritual." After being read the parable of the prodigal son, for instance, a Piraha speaker asked the reader if he knew this man. When the answer was no, the man showed no interest in the story. If it isn't close to firsthand, what's the point?

They have no art beyond art that momentarily exists to express something new. When an airplane lands, boys make model planes from balsa wood. But they're soon discarded and forgotten.

According to Everett, the linguist, these tendencies away from abstraction are not the result of some sort of cognitive deficiency. If a baby was taken out of the forest and raised in the city, she would be perfectly capable of learning another language and thinking in abstractions. Rather, Everett maintains, the difference is cultural. As a culture, the Piraha simply reject the abstract.

One might say they live in the moment.

And that's what's so fascinating to me. I don't want to fall into a sentimental fallacy here. I don't mean to romanticize the Piraha a la the "Noble Savage" ideology of the nineteenth century.

Rather, I'm fascinated that this kind of radical empiricism is possible, that a culture could create and maintain it for centuries.

In the practice of meditation, the intention is to abandon the conceptual, to "be with what is." It seems as if this whole culture is built on that intention.

Good, bad. That's not the point. It's just that it's possible. That there they are, a group of people who live in the moment. They don't store more than a few days' worth of flour. Theravada monks are not allowed to store food. It's the same principle, basically. It's a renunciation of conceptualization. Full attention is on the now, not on some abstract notion like the future.

So, yeah, fascinating.

11 comments:

joanna said...

I read Derek's post, too, and now yours and am fascinated by the tribe--never would have thought to bring it back to Buddhist ideas, though. Interesting stuff.

cc22 said...

角色扮演,
睡衣,
SM,
潤滑液,
情趣玩具,
愛愛,
視訊美女戀愛ing,
視訊美女kk俱樂部,
視訊kk俱樂部,

跳蛋,
G點,
按摩棒,
跳蛋,
飛機杯,
充氣娃娃,
自慰套,
情趣娃娃,
自慰器,
情趣用品,情趣,

songsong_like said...

Young and creative style.
abercrombie and fitch
abercrombie & fitch
You can have a look at it.
Abercrombie and fitch outlet
ED Hardy clothing bring you a super surprise!
ed hardy wholesale clothing
If you really want it.
nike outlet

Jeesie Lee said...

Once you try on the moncler jacket , you will find the Moncler bring you unique charm.
Excellent first time buy Amazon's latest zigtech reebok running shoes, let me very face among the students.
New Balance shoes know very well that everybody gets health conscious once in a while.
moncler jacket
moncler jacken
moncler coats
moncler outlet
Barbour
Duvetica
zigtech reebok
reebok zigtech
reebok easytone shoes
zigtech shoes
New Balance
new Balance Shoes
new Balance Outlet
alexander wang shoes
alexander wang dress
birkenstock gizeh
birkenstock Madrid
birkenstock sandals

dfadf said...

Microsoft Office 2010
Office 2010
Office 2007
Microsoft Office
Microsoft Office 2007
Office 2007 key
Office 2007 download
Office 2007 Professional
Windows 7
Microsoft outlook 2010

ali khan said...

I like what you guys are up too. Such smart work and reporting! Keep up the superb works guys I’ve incorporated you guys to my blogroll. I think it will improve the value of my site :) .advertising | advertisment| production houses in pakistan

colaveri d said...

This is a greet article. I am really appreciated. You have informed useful plan to visitor. Thanks for sharing with us.
Imported Cars in Pakistan | Used Toyota Invincible in Pakistan | Used Lexus in Pakistan | Used Toyota Pirus in Pakistan

colaveri d said...

Nice Post ! I agree with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward to your next updates. I will immediately grab your rss feed to stay privy of any updates.
pakistani matrimony | pakistani matrimonial | pakistani matrimonial sites | pakistani dating

Best Article Websites said...


Hi! This is my first visit to your blog! We are a team of volunteers and new initiatives in the same niche. The blog gave us useful information to work. You have done an amazing job!
Advertising agencies in UK | Mobile apps for university

JAMES DEAN said...

I will be really glad my spouse and I witnessed an excellent website. I am providing an online cricket channel. The person who created this post was a big thank you man for sharing with us.
live espn | live match streaming

JAMES DEAN said...
This comment has been removed by the author.